Interdisciplinarity as an Emergent Property: The Research Project “CINTERA” and the Study of Marine Eutrophication

Abstract

Abstract:Research projects combining different disciplines are increasingly common and sought after by funding agencies looking for ways to achieve environmental, social, and economic sustainability. Creating and running a truly integrated research project that combines very different disciplines is, however, no easy task. Large-scale efforts to create interdisciplinary or transdisciplinary research efforts have reported on their experiences in OPEN ACCESSSustainability 2015, 7 9119 trying to achieve this goal. This article shares the methods, challenges and achievements experienced by a smaller group of researchers who have developed an interdisciplinary approach based on former results of Norwegian and Chilean experiments. The project "A Cross-disciplinary Integrated Eco-system Eutrophication Research and Management Approach" (CINTERA), funded by the Research Council of Norway (RCN, project 216607), brings together the fields of political science, economics, marine biology/oceanography and marine bio-geo-chemistry to improve the understanding of marine eutrophication and its possible socio-economic impacts. CINTERA is a multidisciplinary project that evolved into an interdisciplinary project and in so doing, transformed the attitudes of participants. The transformative process was generated particularly by the need to work closely together in making the CINTERA project useful for policy-makers.

Creating space for sustainability literacy: the case of student-centered symposia

“…Language, and more generally, disciplinary culture, are one of the first challenges to arise. Even when projects come from a single discipline, subdisciplines within a given academic discipline may not communicate or work well with each other (Bailey et al, 2015). For example, scientific jargon might differ between ecologists and geneticists despite both being subdisciplines of biology.…”

“…To succeed, proposals need to be concise, yet they also need to show that the project has a strong scientific basis. Therefore, in the case of interdisciplinary projects, proposals need to draw from a larger and more diverse body of literature than traditional research projects while remaining succinct (Bailey et al, 2015). When applying to a funding agency, this interdisciplinary vision might be perceived as favoring breadth over depth.…”

An interdisciplinary framework for navigating social–climatic tipping points

“…One key challenge of interdisciplinary research on social–climatic tipping points involves expanding on the efforts of closely related disciplines to integrate knowledge from distantly related disciplines that span the social–natural science frontier (Bailey et al, 2015). For example, bringing together social–environmental research fields, such as social and industrial ecology, with diverse social and natural science disciplines, such as history and paleoclimatology, among others.…”

Green Out of the Blue, or How (Not) to Deal with Overfed Oceans

“…Th e third prism addresses mainly eutrophication with a highly contextualized, applied and interdisciplinary research perspective; it is adopted by a variety of scholars who endorse a "sustainability science" label, in works published aft er 2005 (e.g., Bailey et al 2015;Lundberg 2013). Th is prism focuses on describing the complexity of responses of social-ecological systems to massive anthropogenic nutrient inputs, on governance issues and on stakeholder participation to river-basin governance (e.g., Franzén et al 2011;Nunneri and Hofmann 2005).…”