Intergenerational Disadvantage: Learning about Equal Opportunity from Social Assistance Receipt

Abstract

Across the globe there is a growing divide between the wellbeing of those at the top of the socioeconomic ladder and those at the bottom. Despite tremendous economic growth, more than 75 percent of people in developing countries are living in societies that are more unequal today than they were in the 1990s. The link in social and economic wellbeing across generations makes redistributive policy design extremely challenging. Thus, it is important that we look beyond traditional tax-and-transfer programs to find new approaches to supporting disadvantaged families. To this end, it is crucial to understand the mechanisms underpinning the transmission of disadvantage from parents to their children (intergenerational disadvantage).We examine the factors underlying intergenerational disadvantage by analyzing the correlation between parents' and their children's receipt of social assistance across different social assistance payments. We use administrative social security (Centrelink) records linked over time and within families; giving us detailed social assistance trajectories -across the entire social safety net -for a birth cohort of young adults and their families over an 18-year period. Our strategy is to exploit differences in how strongly linked is the receipt of social assistance from parents to children across programs -which differ in their target population and eligibility rules -to learn about how disadvantage is transmitted.We find that young people are not only more likely (1.8 times) to need social assistance if their parents have a history of receiving social assistance; they also need more intensive support, receiving an additional $12,000 of social assistance over an 8-year period. The intergenerational correlation is particularly strong in the case of disability payments, payments for those with caring responsibilities, and parenting payments for single parents. Parental disability and single parenthood are the clearest pathways through which disadvantage is being passed from Australian parents to their children. In contrast, other forms of disadvantage, in particular those stemming from parents' poor labor market outcomes, seem to be easier for young people to overcome. Parental disadvantage may be more harmful to children's later life outcomes if it is more strongly driven by circumstances rather than personal choice.Our results suggest that the playing field is not level for all children. Disparities in young people's outcomes are not simply the result of their -or their parents' -differential efforts; unequal opportunities also play a critical role. Greater policy effort must be devoted to leveling the playing field for children growing up in particularly vulnerable families. ABOUT THE AUTHORS AbstractWe use variation in the extent of generational persistence across social assistance payments to shed light on the factors leading to intergenerational disadvantage. Our administrative data come from the Australian social security system and provide us with detailed social assistance trajectorie...

Collaboration Vouchers: A Policy to Increase Population Wellbeing

“…Through comprehending collaboration via a model such as PILAR, proactive policies may be developed that directly enhance population wellbeing. As a result, wealth-generating, innovative, open-access economies may achieve outcomes such as improved wellbeing and living standards of precarious workers, reducing ensuing wealth inequality and intergenerational disadvantage [121].…”

The Mechanisms Underlying the Intergenerational Transmission of Disadvantage: Three Examples from Australia

“…Recent research from Cobb‐Clark et al (2017) focuses on income support dependence in Australia and investigates whether parents on income support are likely to have children that are welfare reliant in the future. This work is the first to address this issue by exploiting variation in intergenerational mobility across different social assistance programs.…”

Intergenerational Mobility Research: Current Challenges and Future Directions

“…Much of the earlier research on intergenerational mobility extensively assessed how parents’ socioeconomic status is reproduced through their children's educational attainment and early income and occupational status (for reviews read Francesconi and Heckman 2016; Torche 2015). In more contemporary work, the link between parents’ unemployment (usually father's unemployment) and the socioeconomic outcomes of their children has become a frequent topic of study (for a review read Cobb‐Clark et al 2017). Linked to this research are studies that investigate intergenerational welfare dependence primarily focusing on female‐headed sole‐parent households reliant on welfare (see Cobb‐Clark et al 2017).…”

“…In more contemporary work, the link between parents’ unemployment (usually father's unemployment) and the socioeconomic outcomes of their children has become a frequent topic of study (for a review read Cobb‐Clark et al 2017). Linked to this research are studies that investigate intergenerational welfare dependence primarily focusing on female‐headed sole‐parent households reliant on welfare (see Cobb‐Clark et al 2017). Over the last decade, important progress has been made to determine causality thanks to the adoption of sophisticated models including twin, sibling fixed effects and instrumental variables approaches (for a review read Black and Devereux 2011).…”

“…First, association versus causation . As recent studies show (Cobb‐Clark et al 2017; Curry, Mooi‐Reci and Wooden 2019; Mooi‐Reci et al 2019), more important than just measuring the extent of intergenerational mobility is identifying the relative importance of the different causal pathways through which intergenerational disadvantage occurs. Some understudied indirect mechanisms include children's attitudes and perceptions about work, parental emotional distress and marital conflict as well as parental time investments and the quality of parent–child interactions.…”