Background
At present, the guidelines for urology recommend percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) as the preferred treatment for staghorn renal calculi (SRC). However, for complete SRC, it has been questioned by clinicians and patients due to high residual stone rate, complications, repeated hospitalizations and high treatment cost. Anatrophic nephrolithotomy (ANL) is a traditional and classic method for the treatment of SRC. Due to its high trauma and high technical requirements, it is difficult to carry out in primary hospitals, and gradually replaced by PCNL. The purpose of this study is to compare the efficacy of PCNL and ANL in the treatment of complete SRC.
Methods
Overall, 238 patients with complete SRC were divided into mini-PCNL in lateral supine position group, (
n
= 190) and ANL group (
n
= 94) according to treatment for a retrospective cohort study. The calculi parameters, renal function index, comorbidities of calculi, surgical complications, length and frequency of hospitalization, treatment costs, results of postoperative satisfaction survey were compared between the two groups.
Results
The risk of the residual stone rate after mini-PCNL in lateral supine position was 239 times (OR = 238.667,
P
< 0.0001), the number of residual stone 1.3 times (OR = 1.326,
P
< 0.0001), the amount of residual stone 2.2 times (OR = 2.224,
P
< 0.0001) that of ANL. The risk of the cost of initial treatment after mini-PCNL in lateral supine position was 3.3 times (OR = 3.273,
P
< 0.0001), the total cost of treatment 4 times (OR = 4.051,
P
< 0.0001), the total length of hospital stays 1.4 times (OR = 1.44,
P
< 0.0001) that of ANL, the incidence of postoperative renal atrophy was 2.2 times (OR = 2.171,
P
= 0.008) higher in the ANL than in the mini-PCNL in lateral supine position. Glomerular filtration rate (GFR) reduction after ANL was 1.4 times (OR = 1.381,
P
= 0.037) greater than that after mini-PCNL in lateral supine position at 24-month follow-up. The risk of the overall satisfaction of ANL was 58 times (OR = 57.857,
P
< 0.0001) higher than that of mini-PCNL in lateral supine position, the number of branches of staghorn greater than 8 is a high risk factor for the occurrence of residual stone after mini-PCNL in lateral supine position (OR = 353.137,
P
< 0.0001).
Conclusion
Although the risk of renal atrophy and decreased GFR after ANL is higher than that of mini-PCNL in lateral supine position, the efficacy of traditional ANL in the treatment of complete SRC was generally superior to that of mini-PCNL in lateral supine position. Moreover, number of branches of staghorn greater than 8 are the preferr...
