Interpreting whole genome sequencing for investigating tuberculosis transmission: a systematic review

Abstract

BackgroundWhole genome sequencing (WGS) is becoming an important part of epidemiological investigations of infectious diseases due to greater resolution and cost reductions compared to traditional typing approaches. Many public health and clinical teams will increasingly use WGS to investigate clusters of potential pathogen transmission, making it crucial to understand the benefits and assumptions of the analytical methods for investigating the data. We aimed to understand how different approaches affect inferences of transmission dynamics and outline limitations of the methods.MethodsWe comprehensively searched electronic databases for studies that presented methods used to interpret WGS data for investigating tuberculosis (TB) transmission. Two authors independently selected studies for inclusion and extracted data. Due to considerable methodological heterogeneity between studies, we present summary data with accompanying narrative synthesis rather than pooled analyses.ResultsTwenty-five studies met our inclusion criteria. Despite the range of interpretation tools, the usefulness of WGS data in understanding TB transmission often depends on the amount of genetic diversity in the setting. Where diversity is small, distinguishing re-infections from relapses may be impossible; interpretation may be aided by the use of epidemiological data, examining minor variants and deep sequencing. Conversely, when within-host diversity is large, due to genetic hitchhiking or co-infection of two dissimilar strains, it is critical to understand how it arose. Greater understanding of microevolution and mixed infection will enhance interpretation of WGS data.ConclusionsAs sequencing studies have sampled more intensely and integrated multiple sources of information, the understanding of TB transmission and diversity has grown, but there is still much to be learnt about the origins of diversity that will affect inferences from these data. Public health teams and researchers should combine epidemiological, clinical and WGS data to strengthen investigations of transmission.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12916-016-0566-x) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Isoniazid-resistant tuberculosis: a cause for concern?

“…75 A recent study of samples from a particular M. tb clone from KwaZulu-Natal in South Africa indicated that INH resistance ( katG ) mutations arose approximately 30 years earlier than RMP resistance. 76 A previous study from Argentina also placed katG mutations prior to rpoB ones, albeit with a much shorter (3 year) gap and overlapping confidence intervals.…”

Comprehensive Whole-Genome Sequencing and Reporting of Drug Resistance Profiles on Clinical Cases of Mycobacterium tuberculosis in New York State

“…The utility of WGS in retrospective outbreak analyses to more accurately identify clusters and true transmission events between patients has been well documented (20)(21)(22). Recent publications have described the potential of implementing WGS in a clinical setting for rapid resistance profiling of M. tuberculosis.…”

Genomic diversity in autopsy samples reveals within-host dissemination of HIV-associated Mycobacterium tuberculosis

“…These estimates may be even greater when considering longer duration infections, such as those of HIV negative individuals. While the thresholds chosen will depend on the mutation detection sensitivity unique to each study, the frequency of substantial within-patient distances adds weight to the mounting evidence 11,33,38,39 against ruling out epidemiological links on the basis of mutational thresholds between single samples.…”