Interventions Using Regular Activities to Engage High-Risk School-Age Youth: a Review of After-School Programs in Latin America and the Caribbean

Abstract

In this paper, I review an issue that is an urgent challenge in the development field-the effectiveness of after-school programs for preventing school-age youth violence in vulnerable settings in Latin American and the Caribbean. These programs have proliferated in the region and include sports, recreation, music, tutoring, and other focused activities. Given their popularity and because they target known risk factors for violence (such as drop-out from school, poor academic performance, lack of motivation, too much idle time, low quality and quantity of adult supervision, and social isolation), it is critical to examine empirically whether they can be effective prevention strategies. Unfortunately, most rigorous trials of after-school interventions to prevent youth violence have been conducted in developed countries, with far fewer in Latin America. In this review, a broad range of databases was searched systematically. Only six studies in five Latin American and Caribbean countries were identified. Reported results indicate at least some benefits for youth behavior, although not across all youth. Additional concerns regarding how these programs are implemented and whether specific components can be tied to violence prevention are noted. The need for more rigorous evaluation of these programs is noted.

Ending violence in childhood: a global imperative

“…Cid (2017) shows how such everyday activities hold significant promise for preventing violence in childhood.…”

The Use and Effectiveness of the Whole School Approach in School-Based Interventions Addressing Gender-Based Violence in Sub-Saharan Africa: A Systematic Review

“…Researchers who conducted a prior systematic review and meta-analysis found that the effective interventions had a longer duration of follow-up, indicating the importance of the longer follow-up period for an accurate assessment of effectiveness (De Koker et al, 2014). Also, half of the interventions studied ( n = 8) only used one outcome measure to assess intervention effectiveness, thereby necessarily failing to determine the co-occurrence of multiple victimization experiences (polyvictimization), which are common among adolescents and young people (Finkelhor et al, 2007; Logie et al, 2019; Okumu et al, 2022), and in turn missing the opportunity to target and mitigate these harms (Cid, 2017). Almost half of the studies did not report the theoretical basis of the intervention, making it challenging for researchers to test, validate, and improve existing behavior change theoretical frameworks (Sales et al, 2006).…”

Violence in sub-saharan african schools: A scoping review protocol

“…Additionally, the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review Analysis Extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA ScR) will ensure all screening results are reported on (Figure 1) [31]. There is a realisation that children are 'poly-victimised' meaning that they are exposed to multiple forms of violence in more than one setting, thus, positioning the school at the epicentre of ending this scourge is significant [33]. Additionally, schools should be inclusive structures and places where positive social norms and human values such as respect, solidarity and tolerance are promoted and encouraged [8].…”