with Kaposi's sarcoma virus had normal EPO production under normoxic conditions and increased EPO mRNA production under hypoxic conditions, in contrast with the effects of CMV in this cell line. Further studies showed that it was the CMV-IE gene expression (identical to CMV-IE proteins detected in CMV-infected HEPCs and human kidneys with CKD) that directly mediated the lowering of the EPO mRNA. In a clinically relevant cellular study, treatment of the cells with valganciclovir, an inhibitor of CMV-late gene expression, had no effect on EPO mRNA production and supported that IE or early CMV gene expression was required to reduce EPO production. In several additional elegant experiments, the investigators showed that CMV infection reduces EPO mRNA production by inhibiting the expression of hypoxiainduced transcription factor-2a and that there was a dose response with CMV-IE gene expression. The working model shown in Figure 8 by Butler et al. is a brilliant figure synthesizing this novel mechanistic work.A major strength of this study is the authors' use of clinical observations, human biospecimens, animal models, and cell culture experiments to conduct true translational research that addresses an important question for clinicians. The finding of CMV-IE proteins in kidneys from humans with CKD but no overt symptoms of the CMV syndrome is important but must be confirmed in larger prospective studies. These should include studies of immunosuppressed and nonimmunosuppressed patients with native CKD, as well as the effect of CMV on resistance to recombinant EPO therapy. An intriguing extension of this mechanistic study would include a treatment arm to determine the effect of antiviral medications that target CMV on CKD-associated anemia. We applaud this innovative study that has the potential for broad applications in transplantation but more importantly in native CKD, which currently affects .20 million people in the United States.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTSM.E