A variety
of (5 + 2) cycloaddition reactions involving oxidopyridinium
and oxidopyrylium zwitterions are compared to investigate the effects
of nitrogen-for-oxygen substitution on reactivity. Activation barriers
for nitrogen-containing systems are predicted to be larger than those
for analogous oxygen-containing systems. Correlations between barrier
heights and synchronicity of C–C bond formation, changes to
aromaticity, reactant distortion, and interaction energies between
zwitterions and alkenes were assessed, leading to the conclusion that
reactivity depends more on distortion effects (including aromaticity
loss) than on interaction effects (such as those associated with highest
occupied molecular orbital–lowest unoccupied molecular orbital
(HOMO–LUMO) interactions).