Introduction: Congenital brain tumors in the younger pediatric population are rare lesions that are histologically distinct from those in the older pediatric population. Malignant histology is common, with persistently poor outcomes despite accessible neuroimaging and evolving adjuvant therapy. There remains scant literature about the natural history of these patients because of rarity and varied institutional experiences. Methods: A retrospective review was performed of congenital brain tumor patients surgically treated at the Montreal Children’s Hospital (MCH) over a 22-year period. Patients presenting in the first year of life were evaluated for demographic information, presenting symptoms, lesion location, and management. Analysis was by median rank test and χ2 statistics. Results: 13 cases of congenital brain tumors were identified: 5 supratentorial and 8 infratentorial. Median age (p = 0.93) and gender (p = 0.57) did not differ by location, and predominant histologies were choroid plexus papilloma and primitive neuroectodermal tumor. Seizure activity was exclusive to supratentorial lesions (40%, p = 0.03), with hypotonia observed only among infratentorial lesions (50%, p = 0.02). There was equal incidence of hydrocephalus (69%, p = 0.57) and increasing head circumference (38%, p = 0.27) by lesion location. Supratentorial lesions were treated by total resection (n = 3), subtotal resection (n = 1), and biopsy (n = 1). Infratentorial lesions were treated by total resection (n = 1), subtotal resection (n = 2), biopsy (n = 1), no operation (n = 2), and decompressive laminectomy for two spinal lesions. Conclusions: Congenital brain tumor patients represent fewer than 2% of patients treated at MCH. An evolving understanding of management objectives for these lesions requires understanding institutional experiences. Patients with supratentorial lesions frequently present with seizures, hydrocephalus, and macrocrania, and more frequently underwent total resection at surgery.