Spinal schwannomas account for one third of primary spinal neoplasms. Clinical presentation is related to the tumor location. An atypical case of acute paraplegia following a fall, on the ground of a thoracolumbar schwannoma, without intratumoral hemorrhage, in a previously asymptomatic patient is reported. A 58-year-old male patient presented with acute paraplegia, and urinary and bowel incontinence, following a fall. The patient had no previous history of back and/or leg pain or neurological symptoms. Magnetic resonance imaging revealed a subdural mass, as well as a fracture of the right T12-L1 facet joint and the right transverse process. The patient underwent emergency T11-L1 wide laminectomy, exploration of the subdural space and T10-L2 posterolateral transpedicular stabilization and fusion. An intradural, extramedullary mass, causing severe cord compression, was found and excised. Pathology revealed schwannoma, without intratumoral hemorrhage. The patient recovered completely 6 months postoperatively. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report of spinal intradural schwannoma causing sudden paraplegia in a previously asymptomatic patient in the setting of trauma, without intratumoral hemorrhage. Emergency canal decompression and complete excision of the tumor represent the optimal management of such cases.