Religious and spiritual beliefs constitute individual identities and are central to personal world-views. Religion and spirituality of clients and therapists’ enter into the therapy process in multiple ways, and the need to understand their role, particularly in religiously diverse contexts cannot be underscored enough. This article explores the religious and spiritual beliefs and practices of psychotherapists from India, and how they impact their psychotherapeutic practice. An exploratory qualitative study was conducted using a constructivist grounded theory approach, with 16 practising psychotherapists from diverse religious/spiritual orientations. Findings revealed that therapists’ religious/spiritual beliefs and practices were interwoven with the theoretical orientation, permeated therapeutic techniques, helped make meaning of the therapeutic role, and facilitated personal and professional growth. Implications for psychotherapy practice, training, and supervision have been discussed.