Investigating Characteristics of Learning Environments During the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Systematic Review

Abstract

Dramatic change in learning environments during the COVID-19 pandemic highlighted the significance of virtual learning and led to more interactive learning environments. Quick adoption of online and social interactive learning in many universities around the world raised challenges and emphasized the importance of investigating different learning environments. This paper investigates the accelerated transition in education from traditional learning environments through online learning environments to social innovative learning environments, and the latest trends of this change. The stages of transition were divided into three parts: before, during, and after the COVID-19 pandemic, which was the reason for this accelerated change. Features and characteristics of each stage of transition were analyzed and discussed, based on the following factors: edu-space and classrooms, the learning and teaching process, curricular choices, information and communication technology applications, students’ and educators’ perceptions, edu-approaches, and knowledge transformation. A systematic review approach was used to investigate learning environments based on the literature reviews of previous publications. Analysis of these features revealed the main characteristics and differences in each stage. New trends in online learning environments and social innovative learning environments were identified including cloud platforms, massive open online courses, digital learning management systems, open educational resources, open educational practices, m-learning, and social network applications. Finally, this study makes two recommendations: 1) the adoption of online learning environments and social innovative learning environment applications to continue the e-learning process during the pandemic, and 2) the enhanced usage of online learning environments and social innovative learning environment applications in the future by educational institutions and governments.

Digitalization amidst educational crises: A comparative study of the new media literacy (NML) levels of the Philippines and Myanmar

“… Pedagogical Shifts . Schools have transitioned to hybrid or remote learning models, pushing students and educators to adapt to digital tools and online modes of communication despite unreadiness (Al‐Ansi, 2022). Digital Well‐Being and Mental Health .…”

Monitoring methods and student performance in distance education exams

“…To corroborate that the assessment is completed by the student in the online evaluations, the authentication system must be effective (Al Ansi and Al-Ansi, 2020; Al-Ansi, 2022; Alraimi et al. , 2015; Amigud, 2013).…”

“…To corroborate that the assessment is completed by the student in the online evaluations, the authentication system must be effective (Al Ansi and Al-Ansi, 2020;Al-Ansi, 2022;Alraimi et al, 2015;Amigud, 2013). In this authentication process, notable developments include procedures similar to those used in the financial services industry, which use random security questions from the student's profile (Bailie and Jortberg, 2009;Ullah et al, 2012), in addition to more advanced methods that use software to biometrically authenticate students through voice (Rudrapal et al, 2012), digital fingerprints (Clodfelter, 2010), iris eye readers (Li et al, 2018), face recognition (Kar et al, 2012) or others that use several of the aforementioned options (Fenu et al, 2018;Ramu and Arivoli, 2013).…”

STEM education in England: questioning the “leaky pipeline” metaphor

“…The COVID-19 pandemic has underscored the importance of STEM education and careers, accentuating the need for renewed attention to the interplay between STEM identities, human capital and societal resilience. The reliance on scientific knowledge and digital technologies during the crisis was unparalleled, marking a significant turning point in public perception of STEM (Al-Ansi, 2022). This extraordinary dependence on STEM sectors necessitated a substantial shift in human capital, highlighting its role in the successful mitigation of the pandemic.…”