Investigating Serious Games That Incorporate Medication Use for Patients: Systematic Literature Review

Abstract

Background The United States spends more than US $100 billion annually on the impact of medication misuse. Serious games are effective and innovative digital tools for educating patients about positive health behaviors. There are limited systematic reviews that examine the prevalence of serious games that incorporate medication use. Objective This systematic review aimed to identify (1) serious games intended to educate patients about medication adherence, education, and safety; (2) types of theoretical frameworks used to develop serious games for medication use; and (3) sampling frames for evaluating serious games on medication use. Methods PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science databases were searched for literature about medication-based serious games for patients. Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines were followed for article selection. Results Using PRISMA guidelines, 953 publications and 749 unique titles were identified from PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science. A total of 16 studies featuring 12 unique serious games were included with components of medication adherence, education, and safety, published from 2003 to 2019. Of the 12 games included, eight serious games were tested in adolescents, three games were tested in young adults, and one game was tested in adults. Most studies (n=11) used small sample sizes to test the usability of serious games. Theoretical frameworks identified in the 12 serious games included information, motivation, and behavior theory; social cognitive theory; precede-proceed model; middle-range theory of chronic illness; adult learning theory; experiential learning theory; and the theory of reasoned action. Existing reviews explore serious games focused on the management of specific disease states, such as HIV, diabetes, and asthma, and on the positive impact of serious game education in each respective disease state. Although other reviews target broad topics such as health care gamification and serious games to educate health care workers, no reviews focus solely on medication use. Serious games were mainly focused on improving adherence, whereas medication safety was not widely explored. Little is known about the efficacy and usability of medication-focused serious games often because of small and nonrepresentative sample sizes, which limit the generalizability of existing studies. Conclusions Limited studies exist on serious games for health that incorporate medication use. The findings from these studies focus on developing and testing serious games that teach patients about medication use and safety. Many of these studies do not apply a theoretical framework in the design and assessment of these games. In the future, serious game effectiveness could be improved by increasing study sample size and diversity of study participants, so that the results are generalizable to broader populations. Serious games should describe the extent of theoretical framework incorporated into game design and evaluate success by testing the player’s retention of learning objectives.

Mapping Behavioral Health Serious Game Interventions for Adults With Chronic Illness: Scoping Review

“…Two-thirds of studies did not cite a theoretical framework guiding the intervention, trial design, or proposed mechanisms linking the serious game to patient outcomes. This finding is similar to a recent systematic review of serious games [ 69 ]. One implication of this lack of frameworks is the broad list of study outcomes and lack of mechanistic or fidelity assessments.…”

Personalized and Self-Management: Systematic Search and Evaluation Quality Factors and User Preference of Drug Reference Apps in Taiwan

“…To keep users using the app, app developers may need to identify potential users, understand their preferences, and ensure that the apps cater to the requirements of each market segment [ 43 ]. Gamification is a growing trend that can improve patients’ knowledge, skills, and satisfaction effectively, further encouraging better medication management and adherence of patients [ 44 ]. The drug reference app designers, whose primary target audience is the general public, may consider incorporating some gaming/gamification factors in their future designs.…”

A Depth Camera–Based, Task-Specific Virtual Reality Rehabilitation Game for Patients With Stroke: Pilot Usability Study

“…Patients with hemiparetic lower limb dysfunction secondary to first-ever stroke were recruited from the First Affiliated Hospital of Jinan University from January 2015 to September 2016. All patients exhibited mild to severe deficits of the paretic lower extremities (≥3 on the Brunnstrom stages of motor recovery for the proximal part of the lower extremity [30], the hip and knee flexion reach [31]). The exclusion criteria were preexisting lower limb impairment, any painful condition affecting the lower limbs, difficulty standing for at least 30 minutes, severe cognitive impairment (Mini-Mental State Examination score less than 22 points [32]), and severe aphasia.…”