“…Unfortunately, as reviewed by Applewhite (1979) , many of those studies are difficult to interpret as they lack appropriate controls or observations. In a series of papers ( Gelber, 1952 , 1956 , 1957 , 1958 , 1962a , b ), Gelber showed an apparent reinforcement of behavior with a food reward (see ( Gershman et al, 2021 ) for a recent commentary). A platinum wire is lowered repeatedly into a depression slide with paramecia.…”