Intramedullary astrocytomas (IMAs) consist of a heterogeneous group of rare central nervous system (CNS) tumors associated with variable outcomes. A DNA methylation-based classification approach has recently emerged as a powerful tool to further classify CNS tumors. However, no DNA methylation-related studies specifically addressing to IMAs have been performed yet. In the present study, we analyzed 16 IMA samples subjected to morphological and molecular analyses, including DNA methylation profiling. Among the 16 samples, only 3 cases were classified in a reference methylation class (MC) with the recommended calibrated score (≥0.9). The remaining cases were either considered “no-match” cases (calibrated score <0.3, n = 7) or were classified with low calibrated scores (ranging from 0.32 to 0.53, n = 6), including inconsistent classification. To obtain a more comprehensive tool for pathologists, we used different unsupervised analyses of DNA methylation profiles, including our data and those from the Heidelberg reference cohort. Even though our cohort included only 16 cases, hypotheses regarding IMA-specific classification were underlined; a potential specific MC of PA_SPINE was identified and high-grade IMAs, probably consisting of H3K27M wild-type IMAs, were mainly associated with ANA_PA MC. These hypotheses strongly suggest that a specific classification for IMAs has to be investigated.