Involvement of people with dementia in making decisions about their lives: a qualitative study that appraises shared decision-making concerning daycare

Abstract

ObjectiveTo explore how people with dementia, their informal caregivers and their professionals participate in decision making about daycare and to develop a typology of participation trajectories.DesignA qualitative study with a prospective, multiperspective design, based on 244 semistructured interviews, conducted during three interview rounds over the course of a year. Analysis was by means of content analysis and typology construction.SettingCommunity settings and nursing homes in the Netherlands.Participants19 people with dementia, 36 of their informal caregivers and 38 of their professionals (including nurses, daycare employees and case managers).ResultsThe participants’ responses related to three critical points in the decision-making trajectory about daycare: (1) the initial positive or negative expectations of daycare; (2) negotiation about trying out daycare by promoting, resisting or attuning to others; and (3) trying daycare, which resulted in positive or negative reactions from people with dementia and led to a decision. The ways in which care networks proceeded through these three critical points resulted in a typology of participation trajectories, including (1) working together positively toward daycare, (2) bringing conflicting perspectives together toward trying daycare and (3) not reaching commitment to try daycare.ConclusionShared decision making with people with dementia is possible and requires and adapted process of decision making. Our results show that initial preferences based on information alone may change when people with dementia experience daycare. It is important to have a try-out period so that people with dementia can experience daycare without having to decide whether to continue it. Whereas shared decision making in general aims at moving from initial preferences to informed preferences, professionals should focus more on moving from initial preferences to experienced preferences for people with dementia. Professionals can play a crucial role in facilitating the possibilities for a try-out period.

Shared decision-making for people living with dementia in extended care settings: a systematic review

“…A rerun of the searches revealed three additional potentially relevant papers 56–58 ; however, the Alzheimer’s Society report 57 did not focus directly on shared decision-making. The qualitative study appraising how people living with dementia make decisions about daycare 56 confirmed the findings of the review in noting the crucial role that professionals can play in facilitating shared decisions. This work appears to be linked with an included study 52 and would suggest that while there is an ongoing interest in this topic intervention-based work in care home settings remains limited.…”

Life under lockdown and social restrictions - the experiences of people living with dementia and their carers during the COVID-19 pandemic in England

“…This subject has been more widely discussed with regard to excluding visitors to care homes to reduce COVID-19 transmission despite the impact on the quality of life of residents with (and without) dementia [ 18 ], but is equally applicable to the people living with dementia who live at home. While previous research regarding risk taking and decision making by people living with dementia was conducted before this pandemic [ 48 , 49 ], similar guidelines should be developed in order to enable people living with dementia to make their own informed decisions or plans where possible.…”

Reconsidering frameworks of Alzheimer's dementia when assessing psychosocial outcomes

“…“Social process” refers to the experience of dementia as one that is susceptible to sociocultural factors such as positive and negative cultural attitudes and/or exclusion from social roles and relationships. Efforts to reframe Alzheimer's dementia explicitly seek to incorporate the voice of the person living with Alzheimer's dementia by giving them an active role in their care and society [69]. Several studies have documented positive aspects of Alzheimer's dementia [68,70].…”