When non-equilibrium, low-temperature plasmas and catalysts interact, they can exhibit synergistic behavior that enhances the chemical activity above what is possible with either process alone. Unlike thermal catalysis, in plasma-assisted catalysis the non-equilibrium state of the plasma produces reactive intermediates, such as excited species, that may play an important role in the catalytic process. There are two primary plasma-surface mechanisms that could produce this synergy: the effect of the plasma on the catalyst (e.g. enhanced adsorption/reaction of plasma-activated species, change of surface structure/ morphology, hot spots, etc) and the effect of the catalyst on the plasma state. This work focuses on the latter. We use a laboratory-scale, packed bed, dielectric barrier discharge (DBD) reactor to observe the influence of multiple alumina (Al 2 O 3 ) supported, transition metal ammonia (NH 3 ) synthesis catalysts on the plasma electrical and optical properties. We find that while the rates of ammonia synthesis over the materials considered, including