Ionic liquids (ILs) are thought to have unlimited configurability
of the properties through selection of ions, e.g., thermal stability,
nonflammability, and lower toxicity. For the example of a herbicidal
ionic liquid, we decided to test if it is possible to increase the
hydrophobicity of a soluble, easily leachable anionic herbicide, 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic
acid [2,4-D], by pairing it with betaine [Bet] and modified betaine
zwitterions characterized by increasing hydrophobicity. This would
be important in terms of the environmental fate of herbicides. The
resulting adsorption (Freundlich) in agricultural soil was equal to
87–95% for hydrophobic [C12Bet] (K
f = 80.2 mg1–1/
n
L1/
n
/g) and [CAPBet]
(K
f = 31.4) and 3% for hydrophilic [Bet]
(K
f < 1). The adsorption of [2,4-D]
anions was minimal, indicating no statistical effect of the hydrophobicity
of cation on the anion sorption. This was also confirmed by 1H–1H NOESY spectra and calculated interaction energies
between ions. Moreover, toxicity, rhizosphere metabiome, and phytotoxicity
studies revealed the dominant role of hydrophobic surface-active derivatives
of betaines. We suggest the need for a better definition of ILs, as
it is possible that many of the previously described ILs were no longer
an IL after their introduction into the environment and instead became
an independent mixture of ions.