B cells activated by nucleic-acid sensing Toll-like receptor 7 and TLR9 proliferate and secrete immune globulins. Memory B cells are presumably more responsive due to higher TLR expression levels, but selectivity and differential outcomes remain largely unknown. In this study, peripheral blood human B cells were stimulated by TLR7 or TLR9 ligands, with or without IFNα, and compared to activators CD40L plus IL-21, to identify differentially responsive cell populations, defined phenotypically and by BCR characteristics. While all activators induced differentiation and antibody secretion, TLR stimulation expanded IgM+ memory and plasma cell lineage committed populations and favored secretion of IgM, unlike CD40L/IL-21 which drove IgM and IgG more evenly. Patterns of proliferation similarly differed, with CD40L/IL-21 inducing proliferation of most memory and naïve B cells, in contrast to TLRs which induced robust proliferation in a subset of these cells. On deep sequencing of the IgH locus, TLR responsive B cells shared patterns of IgHV and IgHJ usage, clustering apart from CD40L/IL-21 and control conditions. TLR activators, but not CD40L/IL-21, similarly promoted increased sharing of CDR3 sequences. TLR responsive B cells were characterized by more somatic hypermutation, shorter CDR3 segments, and less negative charges. TLR activation also induced long positively charged CDR3 segments, suggestive of autoreactive antibodies. Testing this, culture supernatants from TLR stimulated B cells were found to bind HEp-2 cells, while those from CD40L/IL-21 stimulated cells did not. Human B cells possess selective sensitivity to TLR stimulation, with distinctive phenotypic and genetic signatures.