Irrigation return flow causing a nitrate hot spot and denitrification imprints in groundwater at Tinwald, New Zealand

Abstract

Abstract. Tinwald groundwater exhibits two features stemming from irrigation with local groundwater (i.e. irrigation return flow). The first is increased concentrations of nitrate (and other chemicals and stable isotopes) in a hot spot around Tinwald. The chemical concentrations of the groundwater are increased by recirculation of water already relatively high in chemicals. The irrigation return flow coefficient C (irrigation return flow/irrigation flow) is found to be consistent with the chemical enrichments. The stable isotopes of the groundwater show a similar pattern of enrichment by irrigation return flow of up to 40 % and are also enriched by evaporation (causing loss of about 20 % of the original water mass). Management implications are that irrigation return flow needs to be taken into account in modelling of nitrate transport through soil/groundwater systems and in avoiding overuse of nitrate fertilizer leading to greater leaching of nitrate to the groundwater and unnecessary economic cost. The second feature is the presence of denitrification imprints (shown by enrichment of the δ15N and δ18ONO3 values of nitrate) in even relatively oxic groundwaters. The denitrification imprints can be clearly seen because (apart from denitrification) the nitrate has a blended isotopic composition due to irrigation return flow and N being retained in the soil-plant system as organic-N. The nitrate concentration and isotopic compositions of nitrate are found to be correlated with dissolved oxygen concentration. This denitrification imprint is attributed to localised denitrification in fine pores or small-scale physical heterogeneity where conditions are reducing. The implication is that denitrification could be occurring where it is not expected because groundwater DO concentrations are not low.

Integrated Hydrochemistry and Statistical Methods to Investigate Groundwater Origin and Salinization Process in Arid Regions (Central-eastern Tunisia)

“…The natural concentration of nitrate NO3 in groundwater is habitually very low (typically less than 10 mg/l) (USEPA, 1987), although nitrate concentrations is amplify among, agriculture and industry activity and the domestic e uents. Even if they are very low NO3 concentrations in groundwater can con rm the hypothesis of return ow irrigation waters (Stewart and Aitchison-Earl, 2020).…”

Reply to Anonymous Refereee #2

“…Authors: More recent references including two dealing with irrigation return flow as well as nitrate isotopes have been added (i.e. Wexler et al, 2014, Park et al, 2018, Spalding et al, 2019. R2: Background As mentioned above, some of the detail from the introduction (eg the high nitrate, which is also covered in section 2.4) would be better here.…”