Is Self-Perceived HIV Risk Congruent with Reported HIV Risk Among Traditionally Lower HIV Risk and Prevalence Adult Emergency Department Patients? Implications for HIV Testing

Abstract

Because reliance on patients' self-perceived risk for HIV might mislead emergency department (ED) clinicians on the need for HIV testing, we aimed to measure congruency between self-perceived and reported HIV risk in a traditional lower prevalence, lower-risk cohort. A random sample of 18-to 64-year-old patients at a large academic urban ED who were by self-report not men-who-have-sex-with-men (MSM) or injection-drug users (IDUs) were surveyed regarding their self-perceived and reported HIV risk. Sixty-two percent of participants were white non-Hispanic, 13.8% Black, and 21.2% Hispanic; and 66.9% previously had been tested for HIV. Linear regression models were constructed comparing self-perceived to reported HIV risk. Among the 329 female ED patients, 50.5% perceived that they were ''not at risk'' for HIV, yet only 10.9% reported no HIV risk behaviors, while among the 175 male ED patients, 50.9% perceived that they were ''not at risk'' for HIV, yet only 12.6% reported no HIV risk behaviors. Only 16.9% of women and 15.7% of men who had no self-perceived risk for HIV also reported no HIV risk behaviors. Multivariable linear regression demonstrated a weak relationship between self-perceived and reported risk. Congruency between self-perceived risk and reported HIV risk was low among these non-MSM, non-IDU ED patients.

Barriers and facilitators to HIV testing in people age 50 and above: a systematic review

“…29 However, despite disclosing HIV risk behaviours, some patients still perceive themselves to be low risk. 30,12 In the older population, this low perceived risk may be exacerbated by the perception HIV is a young person's disease. 17 Despite public opinion, evidence shows that many older people remain sexually active; one study indicated the main reason for lack of sex in this group may be physical limitations, not because of lack of desire or opportunity.…”

Predictors of HIV-related risk perception and PrEP acceptability among young adult female family planning patients

“…In considering clinical implications of these findings, it is important for health care providers to be aware of potential ‘incongruence’ between perception and behaviour. For example, if providers rely on patient’s self-perceived risk without assessing behaviour directly, they may miss opportunities to provide appropriate testing or counselling (Pringle, Merchant, & Clark, 2013). While results indicate strong interest in PrEP, further programmatic and implementation research is needed to understand women’s ability to successfully adhere to PrEP, and optimize the role of family planning clinics in this process.…”

Pre‐exposure prophylaxis: awareness, acceptability and risk compensation behaviour among men who have sex with men and the transgender population

“…Continuous variables such as age were dichotomized at the median value. Information on current sexual behaviour, including location for soliciting sexual partners, history of transactional sex, number of sexual partners, alcohol and drug use, frequency of condom use and willingness to discuss HIV/AIDS with a sexual partner, was used to ascertain a "calculated risk score" for each respondent [26,27].…”