Is the Effect Assessment Approach for Fungicides as Laid Down in the European Food Safety Authority Aquatic Guidance Document Sufficiently Protective for Freshwater Ecosystems?

Abstract

In Europe, the European Food Safety Authority aquatic guidance document describes the procedures for the derivation of regulatory acceptable concentrations (RACs) for pesticides in edge‐of‐field surface waters on the basis of tier‐1 (standard test species), tier‐2 (geometric mean and species sensitivity distributions [SSDs]), and tier‐3 (model ecosystem studies) approaches. In the present study, the protectiveness of such a tiered approach was evaluated for fungicides. Acute and chronic RACs for tier‐1 and tier‐2B (SSDs) were calculated using toxicity data for standard and additional test species, respectively. Tier‐3 RACs based on ecological thresholds (not considering recovery) could be derived for 18 fungicides. We show that tier‐1 RACs, in the majority of cases, are more conservative than RACs calculated based on model ecosystem experiments. However, acute tier‐2B RACs do not show a sufficient protection level compared with tier‐3 RACs from cosm studies that tested a repeated pulsed exposure regime or when relatively persistent compounds were tested. Chronic tier‐2B RACs showed a sufficient protection level, although they could only be evaluated for 6 compounds. Finally, we evaluated the suitability of the calculated RACs for 8 compounds with toxicity data for fungi. The comparison shows that the current RACs for individual fungicides, with a few exceptions (e.g., tebuconazole), show a sufficient protection level for structural and functional fungal endpoints. However, more data are needed to extend this comparison to other fungicides with different modes of action. Environ Toxicol Chem 2019;38:2279–2293. © 2019 The Authors. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc. on behalf of SETAC.

Use of Postregistration Monitoring Data to Evaluate the Ecotoxicological Risks of Pesticides to Surface Waters: A Case Study with Chlorpyrifos in the Iberian Peninsula

“…Acute toxicity data from laboratory tests (median effect concentrations 48–96‐h values for immobility and mortality) were obtained from the US Environmental Protection Agency's (2019) ECOTOX database. In cases where more than one toxicity value was available for a given taxon, we applied the rules described by Rico et al (2019b). Briefly, the geometric mean was calculated when more than one toxicity value was reported for the same test duration and the same endpoint of a given taxon; and when one taxon was represented by several endpoints, the value corresponding to the most sensitive relevant endpoint included was selected.…”

Environmental risk assessment of pesticides currently applied in Ghana

“…When the resulting chronic PNEC was higher than the acute one, the acute PNEC was used for the chronic risk assessment. The assessment factors used in the PRIMET model are regarded as conservative for most of the chemicals evaluated in this study (Brock and Van Wijngaarden, 2012;Brock et al, 2016;Van Wijngaarden et al, 2015;Rico et al, 2019;Van Wijngaarden and Arts, 2018).…”

Regional Regulations and Public Safety Perceptions of Quality-of-Life Issues: Empirical Study on Food Safety in China

“…Therefore, normative documents are assigned as a convenience to accomplish a communication that required by regulation [ 46 ]. Apparently, governmental regulation efforts could be specified in normative documents [ 47 ], and regulatory policies can enhance public perceptions of risk controllability with regard to food safety. Hereby, we present hypothesis H1.…”