Is the impact of childhood influenza vaccination less than expected: a transmission modelling study

Abstract

BackgroundTo reduce the burden of severe influenza, most industrialized countries target specific risk-groups with influenza vaccines, e.g. the elderly or individuals with comorbidities. Since children are the main spreaders, some countries have recently implemented childhood vaccination programs to reduce overall virus transmission and thereby influenza disease in the whole population. The introduction of childhood vaccination programs was often supported by modelling studies that predicted substantial incidence reductions. We developed a mathematical transmission model to examine the potential impact of childhood influenza vaccination in Germany, while also challenging established modelling assumptions.MethodsWe developed an age-stratified SEIR-type transmission model to reproduce the epidemic influenza seasons between 2003/04 and 2013/14. The model was built upon German population counts, contact patterns, and vaccination history and was fitted to seasonal data on influenza-attributable medically attended acute respiratory infections (I-MAARI) and strain distribution using Bayesian methods. As novelties we (i) implemented a stratified model structure enabling seasonal variability and (ii) deviated from the commonly assumed mass-action-principle by employing a phenomenological transmission rate.ResultsAccording to the model, by vaccinating primarily the elderly over ten seasons 4 million (95% prediction interval: 3.84 – 4.19) I-MAARI were prevented which corresponds to an 8.6% (8.3% – 8.9%) reduction compared to a no-vaccination scenario and a number-needed-to-vaccinate (NNV) to prevent one I-MAARI of 37.1 (35.5 – 38.7). Additional vaccination of 2-10 year-old children at 40% coverage would have led to an overall I-MAARI reduction of 17.8% (17.1 – 18.7%) mostly due to indirect effects with a NNV of 20.7 (19.6 – 21.6). When employing the traditional mass-action-principle, the model predicted a more than 3-fold higher I-MAARI reduction (55.6%) due to childhood vaccination.ConclusionIn Germany, the introduction of routine childhood influenza vaccination could considerably reduce I-MAARI among all age-groups and improve the NNV. However, the predicted impact is much lower compared to previous studies, which is primarily caused by our phenomenological approach to modelling influenza virus transmission.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12879-017-2344-6) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

A human behavior integrated hierarchical model of airborne disease transmission in a large city

“…There are two types of models of infectious disease transmission: mathematical and behavior models. Simulation of infectious disease transmission based on mathematical models such as SIR [10], SEIS [11], SIRS [12], SEIR [13], and complex networks [14] is generally very fast, but these models do not reflect micro-patterns such as personal contact, which are essential for studying the effects of intervention at the personal and building levels. Models based on human behavior use simulated human activity at hourly intervals to calculate infection probabilities [15,16], but are significantly limited by computational power.…”

A systematic review of the health economic consequences of quadrivalent influenza vaccination

“…Countries with universal influenza vaccination recommendations, such as the US, have relatively high vaccination coverage among children. As children seem to represent an important group in influenza transmission [48,49], the additional impact of dynamic models over static models will be higher in countries with universal vaccination as compared with countries restricting influenza vaccination to elderly and specific high-risk groups. Additionally, when -from a societal perspective -cost savings due to (parental) work loss are taken into account, potentially better cost-effectiveness outcomes may ensue.…”

Influenza in the school-aged population in Mexico: burden of disease and cost-effectiveness of vaccination in children

“…Previous studies have recognised the role of the child population as key spreaders of influenza and that schools, day-care centres, and other places where children congregate play an important role in spreading influenza [34,40,41]. Although high mortality is not usually reported for this group [42], studies have recommended the inclusion of this population as a target group for influenza vaccination based on epidemiological parameters such as the Number Needed to Vaccinate or number of medical consultations [43].…”