Is the press properly presenting the epidemiological data on COVID-19? An analysis of newspapers from 25 countries

Abstract

We conducted a cross-sectional study to assess how the top 3 highest circulation newspapers from 25 countries are comparing and presenting COVID-19 epidemiological data to their readers. Of 75 newspapers evaluated, 51(68%) presented at their websites at least one comparison of cases and/or deaths between regions of their country and/or between countries. Quality assessment of the comparisons showed that only a minority of newspapers adjusted the data for population size in case comparisons between regions (37.2%) and between countries (25.6%), and the same was true for death comparisons between regions (27.3%) and between countries (27%). Of those making comparisons, only 13.7% explained the difference in the interpretation of cases and deaths. Of 17 that presented a logarithmic curve, only 29.4% explained its meaning. Although the press plays a key role in conveying correct medical information to the general public, we identified inconsistencies in the reporting of COVID-19 epidemiological data. Supplementary Information The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1057/s41271-021-00298-7.

Epidemiologia e pandemia de Covid-19: oportunidades para rever trajetórias e planejar o futuro

“…Em algumas situações, a agenda política encurralou a agenda de pesquisa epidemiológica, como parece ser o caso do uso de cloroquina para tratamento de Covid-19 64 . Apesar da grande interação entre Epidemiologia e mídia, a qualidade da apresentação dos dados epidemiológicos nesses veículos ainda carece de maior qualificação 68 .…”

Epidemiology and the Covid-19 pandemic: opportunities to review trajectories and plan for the future

“…In some situations, the political agenda cornered the epidemiological research agenda, as it seems to be the case of the use of chloroquine for treatment of Covid-19 64 . Despite the extensive interaction between Epidemiology and the media, the quality of the presentation of epidemiological data in these vehicles stills needs to improve 68 .…”

Varieties of corona news: a cross-national study on the foundations of online misinformation production during the COVID-19 pandemic

“…This body of work illustrates the significant effect of a number of county-level variables on sources and types of as well as exposure and susceptibility to misinformation. Hence, countries’ levels of uncertainty avoidance [ 46 ]; political and media freedom, and mobile connectivity [ 47 ]; human development [ 48 ]; political conservatism and political control over media [ 49 ]; Gross Domestic Product [ 50 ]; media fragmentation and partisanship [ 51 ] have been found to shape the misinformation environment beyond the individual-level factors.…”