Islamic Jurisprudence as an Ethical Discourse: An Enquiry into the Nature of Moral Reasoning in Islamic Legal Theory

Abstract

This article seeks to develop a better understanding of the normative nature of moral reasoning in Islamic legal theory (us * ul al-fiqh). This theory is built on a foundational proposition suggesting that moral evaluation must conform to the divine will, which aims to achieve an ethical state of affairs expressed as mas : lah : a (social good). Jurists use notions of mas : lah : a to interpret revelatory norms and make new rules to guide moral choices in applied ethics. However, very little is known about mas : lah : a's underlying nature of ethical value and normative content. In modern Islamic studies, mas : lah : a is commonly understood in consequentialist/utilitarian terms. In situations of moral uncertainty, Muslims should aim to promote choices that maximize the good. In this article, I offer three insights into the nature of moral reasoning in Islamic legal theory. First, I show that the common consequentialist/utilitarian thesis of Islamic moral reasoning is unsustainable. Second, both classic and modern Islamic jurisprudence introduced two conflicting visions of Islamic moral reasoning. One is rooted in rudimentary consequentialist approach while the other seems to contemplate deontological normativity in the Islamic system of ethics. Finally, I argue that the way forward is to reconcile these conflicting views in one hybrid normative framework to guide our understanding of the content of ethical value and normativity in Islamic legal theory. In this framework, I understand mas : lah : a as comprising first-order deontological principles to provide categorical protection for basic human needs while leaving room for consequentialist calculations of the right action.

How to program autonomous vehicle (AV) crash algorithms: an Islamic ethical perspective

“…The concept of public interest or welfare often implies material gain in a worldly context, which does not fully embody the depth of maṣlaḥa . Instead, we propose a more holistic depiction of maṣlaḥa , defining it as an ethical state of affairs in alignment with the divine will (Elmahjub, 2021, pp. 16–42).…”

Improving Thinking Skills Through Usul Al-Fiqh Learning: An Action Research on Prospective Islamic Religious Education Teachers

“…However, in practice, Usul Fiqh learning process is typically expository, teacher-centered, and employs the classical lecture approach, which is similar to the learning process in many Islamic boarding schools in Indonesia (Alkouatli, 2018;Wang, 2022). This situation has a direct influence on educational outcomes, which often focus on the memorization of Usul Fiqh concepts and regulations, but fall short in terms of practical application, which is the primary goal of Usul Fiqh (Elmahjub, 2021;Jenkins, 2005). Achieving Usul Fiqh objectives undeniably necessitates changes in the chosen learning methods and design, crafting an educational process that nurtures students' skills to think in a more constructive and context-specific manner when comprehending Usul Fiqh principles.…”