Certain aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases prevent potential errors in protein synthesis through deacylation of mischarged tRNAs. For example, the close homologs isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase (IleRS) and valyl-tRNA synthetase (ValRS) deacylate Val-tRNA Ile and Thr-tRNA Val , respectively. Here we examined the chemical requirements at the 3-end of the tRNA for these hydrolysis reactions. Single atom substitutions at the 2-and 3-hydroxyls of a variety of mischarged RNAs revealed that, while acylation is at the 2-OH for both enzymes, IleRS catalyzes deacylation specifically from the 3-OH and not from the 2-OH. In contrast, ValRS can deacylate non-cognate amino acids from the 2-OH. Moreover, for IleRS the specificity for a 3-O location of the scissile ester bond could be forced to the 2-position by introduction of a 3-O-methyl moiety. Cumulatively, these and other results suggest that the editing sites of these class I aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases have a degree of inherent plasticity for substrate recognition. The ability to adapt to subtle differences in mischarged RNAs may be important for the high accuracy of aminoacylation.The genetic code is based on the accurate aminoacylation of tRNAs by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (1, 2). These enzymes synthesize aminoacyl-tRNA in two steps. The amino acid is first reacted with ATP to give an activated aminoacyl adenylate, and then transesterified to the 3Ј-end of the tRNA. Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases must precisely recognize both amino acid and tRNA substrates to yield the correct product. While the structural diversity of tRNA molecules allows for rigorous selection based on RNA-protein interactions, differentiating between closely related amino acids is more challenging. Years ago, Pauling (3) noted the intrinsic difficulty for isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase in the recognition of isoleucine over valine through simple binding interactions.Valine, which differs from isoleucine by a single methylene unit, is activated by Escherichia coli IleRS 1 only 180-fold less efficiently than isoleucine (4). However, the substitution of valine for isoleucine at isoleucine codons in the cell is less than 1 in 3000 (5). The increased specificity is a result of the RNAdependent editing of misactivated valine by IleRS (6, 7). A highly related class I aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase, valyl-tRNA synthetase, faces a similar dilemma in the accurate aminoacylation of tRNA Val . Threonine, an isostere of valine, is activated at a rate 250-fold reduced from that of valine (8). Like IleRS, ValRS prevents the misincorporation of threonine into proteins through the RNA-dependent editing of misactivated threonine (9).These reactions strictly require the presence of the cognate tRNA (6, 10). In the absence of tRNA, the enzymatically generated misactivated adenylates remain in the active site, sequestered from hydrolysis. Upon addition of cognate tRNA the misactivated amino acids are hydrolyzed, regenerating the free tRNA and amino acid, while converting 1 equivalent of ATP to AMP. A prominent mechanism for editing misactivated a...