It's a gift – Samuel Pepys and Sir William Warren, an account of gifts, bribes and kickbacks

Abstract

Purpose This study aims to investigate an individual’s boundary crossing with regard to bribery, gifts and favouritism in rewarding contracts. Samuel Pepys’s diary was written in the 17th century and through detailed accounts gives insight into his inherent professionalism and his negative opinions around bribery but also his acceptance of “gifts” and awarding of contracts to “friends”.Design/methodology/approach The research uses a narrative approach to study a detailed and reflective personal diary identifying the diarist’s self-exploration and attitudes around the receipt of gifts and the awarding of contracts. This microhistory is presented with a narrative account of a case study of the relationship between the diarist, Pepys and a supplier, Sir W. Warren.Findings The diary illustrates how Pepys crosses these boundaries and how the lack of accountability within his role enables him to do this. This detailed study enables answers to questions that with time, legislation and lack of acceptability, have become more difficult to ask and to answer, about the crossing of boundaries and ethical decisions around the acceptance of bribes and kickbacks.Originality/value A contribution of this paper is the use of a diary, at least a diary as self-reflective as Pepys’s written up as a narrative account. The use of a detailed diary in an accounting microhistory of this nature gives insight and assists in answering difficult to ask questions around personal motivations for bribery and corruption and contributes in this area. The research contributes in developing research around boundaries and the corruption equation using the insight gleaned from this narrative account.

“As bad as bad can be”: accounting for species extinction in the North Pacific

“…We use emancipatory accounting theory (Gallhofer and Haslam, 2002, 2006, 2019) as the lens through which we analyse the company accounts, with analysis following a framework suggested by Atkins and Maroun (2018). In this way, this microhistory (Carnegie and McBride, 2022) uses theory to provide a conceptual framework (Carnegie and Napier, 2017) for historical narrative (McBride, 2023), exploring how sets of accounts and company reporting can illustrate an approach to integrated business, reporting and management of ecology.…”

The picturesque roots of impression management: framing, Claude glass and “rose”-tinted lens?

“…In our analysis we take an interpretive view and analyse the text in a similar way to earlier work which explores historic discourse, for example Atkins et al (2014) in their analysis of William Morris' varied works, Atkins and McBride (2021) in studying Fumifugium as an historical environmental report and McBride (2023) interpreting a case study found within a diary. Milne et al (2009) explored the analysis of dialogue in a critical and interpretive manner.…”