Justice Climates and Management Team Effectiveness: The Central Role of Group Harmony

Abstract

Although social harmony is one of the most important cultural values in many of Asian societies it has rarely been studied in the mainstream management literatures. Based on the group-value theory of justice we examined how group justice climates influence group effectiveness through group harmony. Analyses of data on 106 upper-level management teams from Chinese organizations showed that justice climates were positively associated with group harmony, which in turn was positively associated with team task performance and team helping behavior. Group harmony was found to significantly mediate the positive effect of both distributive and interactional justice climates on team helping behavior but only marginally on team task performance. Finally, in support of past research both at the group and individual level, procedural justice climate had the weakest effect on group processes and outcomes. By applying the group value theory on group harmony this paper aims to integrate Eastern and Western perspectives on one hand and the justice climates and group harmony research on the other. Theoretical and practical implications are discussed.

Preference for Inequality and Ethical Trade-Offs: A U.S. – Turkey Comparison

“…Given these ethical goals are not inherently contradictory, future research may explore boundary conditions under which ethical dilemmas could be creatively resolved in a win-win fashion. For example, research could study how organizations balance economic productivity and social harmony goals to maintain perception of organizational justice (He et al, 2004; Unal et al, 2017).…”

How Do Coworkers Aid in Coping with Emotional Exhaustion? An Experience Sampling Method Approach

“…For the metro policy, the Natural Science Foundation of China called for research facilitating the establishment of harmony and innovative organizational climate. Indeed, group harmony plays the central role in enhancing team cohesion and effectiveness [49,50]. Further, Larson et al addressed that organizational climate can be shaped through intervention [51].…”

Toxic work climates: An integrative review and development of a new construct and theoretical framework.

“…For example, Pecino et al (2018) found that interactional justice climate predicts work–family balance and extrarole behaviors via burnout and engagement. Ünal et al (2017) showed that interactional justice climate has a direct effect on group harmony, which in turn relates to team task and helping behaviors. Seo and Lee (2017) revealed that justice climate can act as a mechanism by which social exchange processes influence group affective tone, a concept that speaks to the dynamics and functionality of groups.…”