Sesquiterpene synthases (STPSs) catalyze carbocation‐driven cyclization reactions that can generate structurally diverse hydrocarbons. The deprotonation‐reprotonation process is widely used in STPSs to promote structural diversity, largely attributable to the distinct regio/stereoselective reprotonations. However, the molecular basis for reprotonation regioselectivity remains largely understudied. Herein, we analyzed two highly paralogous STPSs, Artabotrys hexapetalus(−)‐cyperene synthase (AhCS) and ishwarane synthase (AhIS), which catalyze reactions that are distinct from the regioselective protonation of germacrene A (GA), resulting in distinct skeletons of 5/5/6 tricyclic (−)‐cyperene and 6/6/5/3 tetracyclic ishwarane, respectively. Isotopic labeling experiments demonstrated that these protonations occur at C3 and C6 in AhCS and AhIS, respectively. The cryoelectron microscopy‐derived AhCS complex structure provided the structural basis for identifying different key active site residues that may govern their functional disparity. The structure‐guided mutagenesis of these residues resulted in successful functional interconversion between AhCS and AhIS, thus targeting the three active site residues [L311‐S419‐C458]/[M311‐V419‐A458] that may act as a C3/C6 reprotonation switch for GA. These findings could facilitate the rational design or directed evolution of STPSs with structurally diverse skeletons.