Keeping nurses in nursing: a qualitative study of German nurses’ perceptions of push and pull factors to leave or stay in the profession

Abstract

Background The increasing nursing shortages worldwide has focused attention on the need to find more effective ways to recruit and retain nurses. The aim of this study was to gain understanding of factors that keep German nurses in nursing and explore their perceptions of factors that contribute to nurses leaving or staying in the profession. Methods An explorative qualitative study was undertaken at four different hospitals (two university hospitals and two public hospitals) in Baden-Wuerttemberg, a state in South Germany. Semi-structured face-to-face or telephone interviews were conducted with 21 state-qualified nurses who had graduated from a German nursing program. Each interview was pseudonymized and transcribed. Transcripts were coded according to Qualitative Content Analysis with data structured into themes and subthemes. The study was reported according to the Consolidated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative Studies (COREQ) checklist for qualitative research. Results Two themes emerged from the analysis and each theme had several subthemes: a) PUSH FACTORS i.e. factors that may push nurses to consider leaving the profession included limited career prospects, generational barriers, poor public image of nursing, and workplace pressures; b) PULL FACTORS i.e. factors that nurses wished for and could keep them in the profession included professional pride, improved remuneration, recognition of nursing, professionalisation, and improving the image of nursing as a profession. Conclusion The decision to leave or stay in nursing is influenced by a complex range of dynamic push and pull factors. Nurse Managers responsible for stabilizing the workforce and maintaining their health system will continue to have to navigate challenges until working conditions, appropriate wages and career development opportunities are addressed. A key to tackling nursing shortages may be focusing on pull factors and nurse managers listening in particular to the perspectives of junior nurses directly involved in patient care, as giving them opportunity to further develop professionally, reinforcing a strong and supportive workplace relationships, paying an appropriate salary, and improving the public image of nursing profession. Registration number The study has been prospectively registered (27 June 2019) at the German Clinical Trial Register (DRKS00017465).

Nursing Workforce Retention in Rural Ghana: The Predictive Role of Satisfaction, Rural Fit, and Resilience

“…Tis may be due to inefcient communication about conditions that enhance personal fulflment, professional success, and the delivery of high-quality nursing care. Moreover, the high workload in rural settings combined with low pay and lack of prospects for professional growth could be blamed for the phenomenon [34,35]. Additionally, the fact that most rural hospitals have local conditions where nurses are exposed to poor working conditions and few career chances infuences turnover intention [36].…”

Time to solve persistent, pernicious and widespread nursing workforce shortages

“…This could be similar to how lack of staff continuity adversely impacts patient outcomes and experiences (Van Walraven et al., 2010). In this way, high turnover might be understood to have a compounding effect on top of the plethora of factors that can lead to poorer nurse retention such as lack of professional and career development opportunities (Yang et al., 2015), limited autonomy and capacity to work to full scope of practice and engage in decision‐making (Hara et al., 2020; Pursio et al., 2021), insufficient remuneration (Roth et al., 2022), lack of job flexibility (Wright & Bretthauer, 2010), high patent/client to staff ratios (Chen et al., 2019), poor organisational culture and support (Pedrosa et al., 2021) and bullying and horizontal violence (Blackstock et al., 2015). Strategies to enhance retention should be sensitive to demographic differences.…”

Mapping the Global Research Landscape on the Nurse Resilience Management: A Bibliometric Analysis

“…Unequal leadership opportunities for women in nursing reduce job satisfaction and retention within the profession. Researchers consider nursing to be a high-stress occupation because of the big emotionality, physical and psychic exertion, overlabour, potential burnout (Kelly, 2020;Olaleye et al, 2022), the specific relationship with patients, doctors, and colleagues, bureaucratic inflexibility, modest pay, low job prestige and perspectives (Roth et al, 2022).…”