Key biochar properties linked to denitrification products in a calcareous soil

Abstract

Meta-analyses show an overall decrease in soil N2O emissions after biochar (BC) amendment. Nonetheless, N2O mitigation with BC cannot be extrapolated to every BC-soil combination, inasmuch as an increase in soil N2O release has been occasionally reported. We hypothesized that BC characteristics are key, and performed two microcosm experiments to advance in the understanding of the properties associated. We first investigated how 22 well-characterized BCs affect N2O emissions in a calcareous soil under denitrification conditions. Whereas most BCs decreased N2O emissions, some substantially increased N2O emissions. In a second experiment, we selected and further characterized eight of the 22 previous BCs. We applied the 15N-gas-flux method to study how these BCs affect denitrification products (N2O and N2) in the same soil. Results indicate that the interaction between BC and the denitrification process depends on the temperature of pyrolysis. Whereas BCs produced at 400 °C tended to increase total denitrification (N2O+N2) by an average of 28%, BCs produced at 600 °C significantly reduced total denitrification by 53%. Nevertheless, this decline in overall denitrification did not result in a decrease of N2O emissions, as there was a strong shift in the N2O/(N2+N2O) ratio favoring N2O. A redundancy analysis revealed a direct correlation between carboxylic groups on BCs surface and N2O emissions. This research enhances our understanding of the interaction of BC with denitrification, particularly concerning the relevance of the temperature of pyrolysis, and opens up new paths for investigation, crucial for optimizing the application of BCs in different soil environments. Graphical Abstract