“…Nevertheless, flexibility of the protein is essential for proton transfer [30,32,33]. In the presence of a flexible protein environment, computations with a pair of reactant and product states shown to be compatible with active proton pumping indicated an energy barrier of *12 kcal/mol, and the reaction was almost isoenergetic [30] (the enthalpic barrier estimated from experiments for the first proton-transfer step is *13 kcal/mol [34]). When only the active site groups (retinal, K216, D85, T89, D212, and w402) were allowed to move, the proton transfer barrier and the reaction energy were *23 kcal/mol and *11 kcal/mol, respectively [32,33].…”