In the present paper (1) the Hall method (HM) (specifically designed for determining the interdiffusion coefficient at the low and high composition limits of the corresponding interdiffusion composition profile) is further developed in order to be applied to the whole composition profile resulting in the Extended Hall method (EHM); (2) A comparative study of the HM, EHM, Boltzmann-Matano (BM) and Sauer and Freise (SF) methods is performed using composition profiles generated by computer simulation. The results clearly indicate that the HM/EHM technique is only applicable when the interdiffusion coefficient is constant (i.e. independent of composition) or almost constant at the low composition regions. In all other cases, the BM and SF methods give the best agreement with the input interdiffusion function even at the ends of the composition profiles.