“…Naturally, the question was raised on the origin of RPWs: two concepts were proposed. The first one is that RPWs are real waves propagating horizontally across the penumbra (Alissandrakis, Georgakilas, and Dialetis, 1992;Tsiropoula, Alissandrakis, and Mein, 2000;Tziotziou et al, 2004Tziotziou et al, , 2006; and the second concept implies them to be an apparent effect-a result of waves rising to the surface along inclined magnetic tubes, thus appearing first at the inner penumbra and then farther from the sunspot centre (Rouppe van der Voort et al, 2003;Bogdan and Judge, 2006;Kobanov, Kolobov, and Makarchik, 2006;Bloomfield, Lagg, and Solanki, 2007;Kobanov, Kolobov, and Chupin, 2008;Cho et al, 2015). The same effect is also deemed to be responsible for umbral flashes; and indeed, recently, researchers tend to consider umbral flashes and RPWs as manifestations of one phenomenon (Madsen, Tian, and DeLuca, 2015).…”