The Deep Western Boundary Current (DWBC) is a major conduit for the equatorward export of dense waters formed in the subpolar North Atlantic and Nordic Seas that constitute the lower limb of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation. Here, we investigate the extent to which there is coherent propagation of property anomalies along the DWBC from the Labrador Sea exit to 26.5°N. Past studies have focused on relationships between DWBC anomalies at selected sites. Here we use a hydrographic data set (EN4) that covers the time period of 1970–2020 to examine coherence continuously along the boundary current. Our findings reveal sharp differences between the upper and deep Labrador Sea Water (uLSW, dLSW). Specifically, dLSW property anomalies are highly correlated at all points downstream to the Labrador Sea exit. Furthermore, the lags that yield maximum correlations uniformly increase with distance along the boundary. uLSW, however, shows a sharp decline in coherence along the boundary such that the anomalies downstream are poorly correlated with those at the Labrador Sea exit and the lag times are not monotonic. Most of the decline in uLSW coherence occurs from the Labrador Sea exit to Flemish Cap, where local variability at uLSW densities is large. Our study sheds light on the competition between advected property variability and local property variability that impacts the identification of anomalies downstream. The uLSW and dLSW differences expressed along the DWBC are also evident offshore, consistent with past Lagrangian studies.