Materials with a large magnetocaloric response are associated with a temperature change upon the application of a magnetic field, and are of interest for applications in magnetic refrigeration and thermomagnetic power generation. The usual metric of this response is the gravimetric isothermal entropy change ∆SM . The use of a simple proxy for the ∆SM that is based on density functional theory (DFT) calculations of the magnetic electronic structure, suggests that half-Heusler MnNiSb should be a better magnetocaloric than the corresponding Heusler compound MnNi2Sb. Guided by this observation, we present a study of MnNi1+xSb (x = 0, 0.25, 0.5, 0.75, 1.0) to evaluate relevant structural and magnetic properties. DFT stability calculations suggest that the addition of Ni takes place at a symmetrically distinct Ni site in the half-Heusler structure, and support the observation using synchrotron X-ray diffraction of a homogeneous solid solution between the half-Heusler and Heusler endmembers. There is a maximum in the saturation magnetization at x = 0.5, and the Curie temperature systematically decreases with increasing x. ∆SM for a maximum magnetic field change of ∆H = 5 T monotonically decreases in magnitude from −2.93 J kg −1 K −1 in the half-Heusler to −1.35 J kg −1 K −1 in the Heusler compound. The concurrent broadening of the magnetic transition results in a maximum in the refrigerant capacity at x = 0.75. The Curie temperature of this system is highly tunable between 350 K and 750 K, making it ideal for low grade waste heat recovery via thermomagnetic power generation. The increase in ∆SM with decreasing x may be extendable to other MnNi2Z Heusler systems that are currently under investigation for use in magnetocaloric refrigeration applications.