Roll-to-roll manufacturing systems have been widely adopted for their cost-effectiveness, eco-friendliness, and mass-production capabilities, utilizing thin and flexible substrates. However, in these systems, defects in the rotating components such as the rollers and bearings can result in severe defects in the functional layers. Therefore, the development of an intelligent diagnostic model is crucial for effectively identifying these rotating component defects. In this study, a quantitative feature-selection method, feature partial density, to develop high-efficiency diagnostic models was proposed. The feature combinations extracted from the measured signals were evaluated based on the partial density, which is the density of the remaining data excluding the highest class in overlapping regions and the Mahalanobis distance by class to assess the classification performance of the models. The validity of the proposed algorithm was verified through the construction of ranked model groups and comparison with existing feature-selection methods. The high-ranking group selected by the algorithm outperformed the other groups in terms of training time, accuracy, and positive predictive value. Moreover, the top feature combination demonstrated superior performance across all indicators compared to existing methods.