Steroids can be difficult to modify via traditional organic synthesis methods, but many enzymes regio- and stereo-selectively process a wide variety of steroid substrates. We tested whether steroid-modifying enzymes could make novel steroids from non-native substrates. Numerous genes encoding steroid-modifying enzymes, including some bacterial enzymes, were expressed in mammalian cells by transient transfection and found to be active. We made three unusual steroids by stable expression in HEK293 cells of the 7α-hydroxylase CYP7B1, which was selected because of high native product yield. These cells made 7α,17α-dihydroxypregnenolone and 7β,17α-dihydroxypregnenolone from 17α-hydroxypregnenolone, and produced 11α, 16α-dihydroxyprogesterone from 16α-hydroxyprogesterone. The latter two products resulted from previously unobserved CYP7B1 hydroxylation sites. A Rosetta docking model of CYP7B1 suggested that these substrates’ D-ring hydroxylations may prevent them from binding in the same way as the native substrate, bringing different carbons near the active ferryl oxygen. This new approach could use other enzymes and substrates to produce many novel steroids for drug candidate testing.