Leadership gender disparity in the fifty highest ranking North American universities: Thematic analysis under a theoretical lens

Abstract

BackgroundDespite changes in the discourse around gender distributions within academic leadership, women continue to be under-represented in academia. Our study aims to identify the extent of gender disparity in the academic leadership in the top 50 North American universities and to critically analyse the contributing factors through a comprehensive theoretical framework.MethodsWe adopted the theoretical framework of leadership continuum model. A retrospective analysis of the gender of the leadership ranks was conducted between December 2018 and March 2019 for the top 50 universities in North America (2019 Quacquarelli Symonds World University Ranking system). The leadership hierarchy was classified into six tiers.ResultsA total of 5806 faculty members from 45 US and five Canadian universities were included. Women were overall less likely to be in a senior leadership role than men (48.7% vs 51.3%; p value=0.05). Women accounted for fewer positions than men for resident/chancellor (23.8% vs 76.2%; p value<0.001), vice-president/vice-chancellor (36.3% vs 63.7%; p value<0.001), vice provost (42.7% vs 57.3%; p value=0.06), dean (38.5% vs 61.5%; p value<0.001) and associate dean (48.2% vs 51.8%; p-value=0.05). Women however were in a greater proportion in the assistant dean positions (63.8% vs 36.2%; p value<0.001).ConclusionLeadership gender imbalance is trans-organisational and transnational within the top 50 universities of North America and progressively widens towards the top leadership pyramid. This correlates with the lack of women leadership progress and sustainability in later cycles of the leadership continuum model (beyond assistant dean).

Exploring the Factors Influencing Gender Disparity in STEM Education: A Comprehensive Analysis of Societal, Cultural, and Economic Impact

“…Initiatives aimed at tackling institutional elements must involve alterations in policies and the application of gender-aware course materials that contradict stereotypes and promote inclusiveness (Azizi, et al 2022). The promotion of female teacher representation across all disciplines can act as a source of varied role models.…”

“…The effects are particularly noticeable in relation to the rates at which students abandon their studies and their academic accomplishments (Azizi, et al 2022). Young women who confront impediments resulting from gender-based discrimination demonstrate a tendency to terminate their schooling prematurely, which restricts their career options and exacerbates the cycle of impoverishment.…”

Influences of the Social Media Continuum Model in Radiology: Theory and Reality

“…Social media is a powerful, gender-neutral tool that can enhance women radiologists’ visibility among peers and promote their career advancement. 26 For example, in highly male predominant specialities, such as cardiothoracic surgery in which men have been noted to comprise greater than 95% of the workforce, social media has provided opportunities for women to garner same-gender mentorship that is often lacking within their department. 27…”

Gender Diversity, Leadership, Promotion, and Opportunity Among the Members of the Orthopaedic Trauma Association (OTA)

“…Despite the large pool of women in the academic medicine system, relatively few ascend to top leadership positions. [8][9][10][11] It is widely accepted that women are underrepresented in academic faculty positions and leadership roles as shown by studies conducted in Canada, 12 USA, [13][14][15] European Union, 16 and Australia. 17 Again, this trend is evident across faculties, divisions, departments, and institutions.…”