Learning from Narrated Animations with Different Support Procedures: Working Memory Capacity Matters

Abstract

The present experiment tested the effects of cueing (spotlights) and of verbal instructions in narrated animations on learning outcomes as well as potential moderator effects of working memory capacity (WMC). We found that the spotlight group dwelled longer on parts that were in the focus of the narration than a no-support group (control group). Despite higher levels of experienced difficulties, the no-support group had higher learning outcomes. More importantly, we found an aptitude-treatment interaction: Students with low WMC were impeded by verbal instruction, whereas students with high WMC were impeded by spotlights. Mediation analyses showed that spotlights increased attention to the focus of the narration that fostered learning outcomes but did not lead to better learning outcomes. Our findings suggest that further research on support procedures for animations should (i) take WMC into account, (ii) consider possible negative side effects, and (iii) address processes that mediate the effects.

Demonstration-based training (DBT) in the design of a video tutorial for software training

“…Equivocal findings have been reported for the contribution of signaling to learning outcomes. Some studies have found significant effects (e.g., Amadieu et al 2011;Boucheix and Guignard 2005;Jin 2013), while others have found no significant effects on learning outcomes even when the signals effectively served their attention-guiding role (e.g., de Koning et al 2010;Kriz and Hegarty 2007;Skuballa et al 2012). None of these studies reported negative effects of signaling on learning, however.…”

Supporting motivation, task performance and retention in video tutorials for software training

“…Empirical research on signaling warns that effective support for a single observational learning process (i.e., attention) does not necessarily yield greater learning (de Koning et al 2010;Kriz and Hegarty 2007;Skuballa et al 2012). In other words, this research suggests that it is desirable to obtain process measures for other activities involved in observational learning as well.…”

Educação mediada por tecnologia em Fonoaudiologia: impacto na motivação para aprendizagem sobre o Sistema Miofuncional Orofacial

“…Differences in the ability to control attention and keep the information objects and goals presented to the students affect how much they may benefit from visual cues and information shown during the learning process (28) . The novelty and allure of technology-assisted learning environments stimulate students' curiosity and improve their attention levels during learning (23) .…”