Diversity in Higher Education implies being able as teachers to meet students' needs and preferences to motivate them and facilitate their development and learning. This diversity derives, among others, from students' learning styles and strategies which can determine their academic success or failure. The purpose of this study was to examine student teachers' learning strategies and to determine whether these strategies differ according to some demographic variables (i.e. gender, Bachelor's degree, year of study) and students' academic performance. To this end, a cross-sectional survey design was conducted, and a convenience sample of 141 student teachers (20 males and 121 females) participated in the study. Students were enrolled in the first and second year of two Bachelor's degrees in Education: Early Education (n = 75) and Elementary Education (n = 66). Participants' age ranged between 18 and 42 years old (M = 19.88, SD = 2.73). The 5-point Likert scale questionnaire CEVEAPEU (Gargallo, Suárez-Rodríguez, & Pérez-Pérez, 2009) was administered during class time and descriptive and inferential analyses were conducted. Overall, student teachers report high intrinsic motivation, task value and internal attributions, as well as high levels of self-efficacy and expectations. Concerning strategies related to information processing, students highlighted the elaboration, transfer and use of information. Female students showed greater intrinsic motivation and anxiety control than males and used more strategies related to information elaboration, organization and transfer. Early education student teachers scored higher than elementary education student teachers in motivational, affective and information search and selection strategies. Second-year students showed greater motivational strategies than first-year students. They also scored higher in metacognitive strategies such as planning and in information processing and use strategies. Unexpectedly, students with lower academic performance, reported greater use of planning strategies and other strategies related to information processing, compared to those with average academic achievement. Differences in students' learning strategies highlight the need for accommodating the teaching styles to the characteristics of university students and also the development of programs oriented towards the improvement of students' strategic learning.