A patient with a history of rheumatic mitral valve disease and valve replacement in childhood presented with severe, persistent dyspnea. During an electrophyisiologic procedure, she was discovered to have a fistula from the left ventricle to the coronary sinus. She had severe pulmonary hypertension and elevated filling pressures, with a significant left-to-right shunt. Percutaneous closure of the fistula was performed using two vascular plugs. Subsequently the patient's hemodynamics improved and her symptoms subsided. Here, we describe the case and review the literature.