Susan Silbey (2005: 358) argued that studies of the politics of law needed to take on the creation of consensus at a time of war and polarization when governing is in the hands of wealthy elites. Since she wrote, wars continue, polarization has deepened, authoritarianism has more powerful and vocal advocates, and the electronic media she references have spread. This introduction will take the contests over what courts are for in the context Silbey described.