Lessening the adverse effect of the semivariogram model selection on an interpolative survey using kriging technique

Abstract

Objective Many parameters in environmental, scientific and human sciences investigations need to be interpolated. Geostatistics, with its structural analysis step, is widely used for this purpose. This precious step that evaluates data correlation and dependency is performed thanks to semivariogram. However, an incorrect choice of a semivariogram model can skew all the prediction results. The main objectives of this paper are (1) to simply illustrate the influence of the choice of an inappropriate semivariogram model and (2) to show how a best-fitted model can be selected. This may lessen the adverse effect of the semivariogram model selection on an interpolation survey using kriging technique.MethodsThe influence of the semivariogram model selection is highlighted and illustrated by thematic maps drawn using four different models (Gaussian, magnetic, spherical and exponential). Then, a guideline to select the most suitable model, using mean error (ME), mean square error (MSE), root mean square error (RMSE), average standard error (ASE), and root mean square standardized error (RMSSE), is proposed.ResultsThe choice of a semivariogram model seriously influences the results of a kriging survey at both endpoints and amplitude of the range of the estimated values. However, the direction of variation of the interpolated values is independent of the semivariogram model: different semivariogram models (with the same characteristics) produce different thematic maps but, the areas of minimum and maximum values remain unchanged. Yet, the suitable model can be selected by means of ME, MSE, RMSE, ASE and RMSSE.ConclusionThe present article illustrates how the use of an inappropriate semivariogram model can seriously distort the results of an evaluation, assessment or prediction survey. To avoid such an inconveniency, a methodical approach based on the computation and analysis of ME, RMSE, ASE, RMSSE and MSE is proposed.

Spatial Analysis and Geomorphic Characteristics of Coral Reefs on the Eastern Part of Lombok, Indonesia

“…Kriging was used in this study since the data is normally distributed and stationary. Furthermore, Kriging is the most excellent interpolation method since it is unbiased, it performs better, and had the smallest error values (Zimmerman et al, 1999;Schwendel et al, 2012;Arun, 2013;Arétouyap et al, 2016;Mutaqin et al, 2019a).…”

Investigation of the spatial variation of sediments heavy metals along the Nun River using kriging interpolation technique

“…To study the spatial variation of heavy metals, present in sediments around the Nun River, five semivariogram models (stable, spherical, circular, exponential and K-Bessel) were fitted for each of the four critical parameters (heavy metals) used for geospatial analysis. To choose the model that best described each of the four critical parameters, four goodness-of-fit statistics expressed in equations ( 1) -(4) [18], namely, mean square error (MSE), root mean square error (RMSE), root mean square standardized error (RMSSE) and average standard error (ASE) were utilized.…”

“…The accurate estimation, the MSE, RMSE and ASE indices should be as small as possible whereas the RMSSE index should be as close to unity as possible. If RMSSE is greater (less) than 1, then the variability of the estimations is underestimated (overestimated) [18]. The choice of considered indices was based on their ability to adequately evaluate the fitted distribution and determine the goodness-of-fit between observed and estimated parameters.…”

Downscaling GRACE Remote Sensing Datasets to High-Resolution Groundwater Storage Change Maps of California’s Central Valley

“…In this case, a spherical semivariogram resulted in the lowest mean error, average standard error, and root mean square error when compared to pentaspherical and exponential semivariograms. We followed the procedures outlined in [84,85] for semivariogram selection. One kriged map was created for each year.…”