The studies presented here explore the relationship between protein packing and molecular flexibility using ligand-binding cavity mutants of T4 lysozyme. Although previously reported crystal structures of the mutants investigated show single conformations that are similar to the WT protein, site-directed spin labeling in solution reveals additional conformational substates in equilibrium exchange with a WT-like population. Remarkably, binding of ligands, including the general anesthetic halothane shifts the population to the WT-like state, consistent with a conformational selection model of ligand binding, but structural adaptation to the ligand is also apparent in one mutant. Distance mapping with double electron-electron resonance spectroscopy and the absence of ligand binding suggest that the new substates induced by the cavity-creating mutations represent alternate packing modes in which the protein fills or partially fills the cavity with side chains, including the spin label in one case; external ligands compete with the side chains for the cavity space, stabilizing the WT conformation. The results have implications for mechanisms of anesthesia, the response of proteins to hydrostatic pressure, and protein engineering.EPR | site-directed spin labeling | DEER | benzene | saturation recovery G lobular proteins have overall packing densities similar to those of crystalline solids (1) but nevertheless contain cavities and pockets that can range from a few to hundreds of cubic angstroms (2, 3). These native packing defects are generally destabilizing (4, 5), and improving the packing of the protein interior may be a general way to increase protein stability. Indeed, small-to-large mutations that fill native cavities can increase stability (6-8), but with a concomitant loss of function (7,8). Thus, cavities in the protein interior can play a critical role in function. One role of cavities may be to allow alternative packing arrangements of the core. The resulting ensemble of conformational substates could give rise to promiscuity in protein-protein interactions (9) and allosteric behavior (7,8,10). In addition, large-to-small mutations that generate cavities may have played an important role in the evolution of protein function (11).Considering the potentially important role of cavities in sculpting the energy landscape of proteins, the present study was undertaken to investigate, in solution, the structural and dynamical response of a protein to engineered cavities introduced by large-tosmall mutations. T4 lysozyme (T4L) was selected for study because of the large database of crystal structures of ligand-binding cavity mutations and the corresponding thermodynamic characterization from Matthews and coworkers (4,(12)(13)(14)(15). Remarkably, comparison of the WT and mutant structures showed very little difference or limited local relaxation near the cavity, although the mutations were strongly destabilizing (4, 15).In the present study, we examined the cavity-creating mutants L121A/L133A, L133G, and W138A in sol...