Lessons from tropical storms Urduja and Vinta disasters in the Philippines

Abstract

Purpose Tropical storms Urduja and Vinta battered the Philippines in December 2017. Despite advances in disaster risk reduction efforts of the country, the twin December storms caused numerous deaths in the Visayas and Mindanao regions. Analysis of these events shows that alerts raised during the Pre-Disaster Risk Assessment (PDRA) for both storms were largely ineffective because they were too broad and general calling for forced evacuations in too many provinces. Repeated multiple and general warnings that usually do not end up in floods or landslides, desensitize people and result in the cry-wolf effect where communities do not respond with urgency when needed. It was unlike the previous execution of PDRA from 2014 to early 2017 by the National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council (NDRRMC), which averted mass loss of lives in many severely impacted areas because of hazard-specific, area-focused and time-bound warnings. PDRA must reinstate specific calls, where mayors of communities are informed by phone hours in advance of imminent danger to prompt and ensure immediate action. Mainstreaming Climate Change Adaptation and Disaster Risk Reduction information using probabilistic (multi-scenario) hazard maps is also necessary for an effective early warning system to elicit appropriate response from the community. The paper aims to discuss these issues. Design/methodology/approach Methods of early warning through the PDRA of the National Disaster Mitigation and Management Council (NDRRMC) of the Philippines during tropical storm Urduja and Typhoon Vinta were assessed in this study and compared to the previous PDRA system from 2014 to early 2017. Findings It was found out that the numerous casualties were due to inadequate warning issued during the approach of the tropical cyclones. During an impending hazard, warnings must be accurate, reliable, understandable and timely. Despite the availability of maps that identified safe zones for different communities, warnings raised during the PDRA for both tropical cyclones were deemed too general calling for evacuations of whole provinces. As such, not all communities were evacuated in a timely manner because of failure in the key elements of an effective early warning system. Originality/value To avoid future disasters from happening, it is recommended that the PDRA reinstate its hazards-specific, area-focused and time-bound warnings. Similarly, to increase the resilience of communities, more work on mainstreaming of Climate Change Adaptation and Disaster Risk and Vulnerability Reduction systems for communities must be done as well. Learning from the lessons of these previous disasters will enable communities, their leaders and every stakeholder, not to repeat the same mistakes in the future.

Vulnerability Assessment of Pacific Whiteleg Shrimp (Penaeus vannamei) Farms and Vendors in Davao, Philippines Using FishVool

“…second is the impacts on other food production sectors that affect people's food security and livelihoods [31,[34][35][36], and third is the impacts on aspects of people's lives unrelated to their economic activities, such as diseases or damage to their homes [37][38][39][40]. The growing occurrence of disasters and extreme weather events, as well as the consequences of a changing climate have a composite impact on aquatic ecosystems and the livelihoods of those who depend on them.…”

Exploring the Disproportionate Impact of Disasters: Social Service Providers’ Perceptions of Factors Increasing Vulnerability Among Hurricane Survivors

“…Providers described how prior experience desensitized clients to hurricane risk, thereby reducing their level of preparedness and likelihood to evacuate. Desensitization can develop from false alarms or other inaccurate disaster communication to the public, resulting in failure of urgent community responses even in high-risk disasters (Lagmay & Racoma, 2019; Lim et al, 2019). The findings of this study point to frequency of disaster exposure as another factor leading to desensitization and reduced risk perception.…”

“…Findings from our study highlighted how lack of knowledge influenced vital decision-making during the disaster, as well as the extent to which individuals accessed appropriate services post-disaster. Access to disaster information is crucial; in one study, it was found that many casualties from a tropical storm were directly related to the insufficient warnings issued leading up to the event (Lagmay & Racoma, 2019). Notably, Prelog and Miller (2013) found that the presence of information about the risk of disasters is not always clearly related to individuals' preparedness and protective behaviors and that individual perception of risk also plays a factor in decision-making.…”

Benchmarking household storm surge risk perceptions to scientific models in the Philippines

“…However, there remains a gap in unpacking perceptions to understand the nuances of perceptions across different population segments and differences across severity of storm surge in the Philippines. More broadly, there is a need to position perceptions in the context of risk, integrating vulnerability to understand the differential of storm surge perceptions and consequences on potential impact (Lagmay and Racoma 2019).…”