Lessons learned from 10 years of citizenship education in Northern Ireland: A critical analysis of curriculum change

Abstract

Curriculum change is an intricate, lengthy process, requiring commitment, co-operation and compromise amongst the agencies and stakeholders involved; its development is more complex in divided societies, particularly when the subject content is open to contention. The addition of Local and Global Citizenship to the Northern Ireland curriculum in 2007 was intended to prepare students for life in a post-conflict and increasingly diverse society, and the precariousness of current events locally and globally have reinforced its relevance. Yet, the initial curricular aspirations underpinning citizenship education have been largely unfulfilled and its diminished status within the education system reflects the divergences that beset its development and implementation.This paper employs Fullan's change model of implementation to critically reflect on the interplay of factors that informed and influenced the design and introduction of the Local and Global Citizenship curriculum in Northern Ireland. Using Fullan's framework as an analytic tool, interviews with key stakeholders directly involved in curriculum reform at the time illustrate how the complexity of change motivated and undermined in equal measure.Whilst the paper assesses the implications of a dislocated citizenship curriculum and identifies lessons learned for Northern Ireland, the findings have wide-ranging relevance for education systems generally.

Scientific literacy and agency within the Chilean science curriculum: A critical discourse analysis

“…Moving from one curriculum to another could entail contradictory discursive changes (O’Connor et al, 2020) regarding teachers and students' roles and the understanding of the nature of a discipline, such a science. This research aims to critically analyse the discourses and visions of scientific literacy presented in the secondary science curriculum in Chile.…”

Students’ Perspectives on Civic Education through Digital Citizenship in The Virtual Era

“…People often use digital technology to store data in the present era, although rights and obligations have been abused. According to O'Connor et al (2020), one form of digital crime is personal data trading, a costly illegal sale, and purchase of private information to achieve profitable interests (O'Connor et al, 2020). Therefore, the protection of digital data was recommended for the security of personal rights.…”

“…Digital ethics is the personal ability to realize, set an example, adapt, rationalize, consider, and develop online governance daily. It is used to perform activities or behaviors, indicating that the daily implementation of the Internet is an event in the digital world (Jesson et al, 2015;O'Connor et al, 2020;Weinberg & Flinders, 2018). Moreover, digital media should apply good ethics and focus on positive elements to achieve a common good.…”

Three-faced: The conflicting roles of citizenship education in conflict-affected societies – A comparison of Northern Ireland and Israel

“…Young people can take a public examination in Learning for Life and Work of which Local and Global Citizenship comprises one unit. Despite its status as a compulsory subject, it is notable that recent research has acknowledged that LGC is not liable for the same level of statutory inspection by the Education and Training inspectorate as other subject areas (O'Connor et al, 2020). It is also clear that recent reports are cautious in their assessment of its implementation.…”