The specialization inequality in tropical geometry gives an upper bound for the rank of a divisor on a curve in terms of a combinatorial quantity known as the rank of the specialization of the divisor on the dual graph of the special fiber of a degeneration [6]. This bound can be sharpened by incorporating additional information about the components of the special fiber, giving augmented graphs [2] or metrized complexes [1]. All of these inequalities can be strict because there may be many algebraic curves and divisors with the same specialization. Thus, the natural question is whether, for a given graph and divisor on that graph, the inequality is sharp for some algebraic curve and divisor. If R is the discrete valuation ring over which the degeneration of the curve is defined, we will refer to such a curve and divisor as a lifting of the graph with its divisor over R. In this paper, we show that the existence of a lifting can depend strongly on the characteristic of the field:
lift over k[[t]] if and only if the characteristic of k is in P, and Ŵ ′ and D ′ lift over k[[t]] if and only if the characteristic of k is not in P.We also show that the existence of a lift depends on the field even beyond characteristic:Abstract Tropical geometry gives a bound on the ranks of divisors on curves in terms of the combinatorics of the dual graph of a degeneration. We show that for a family of examples, curves realizing this bound might only exist over certain characteristics or over certain fields of definition. Our examples also apply to the theory of metrized complexes and weighted graphs. These examples arise by relating the lifting problem to matroid realizability. We also give a proof of Mnëv universality with explicit bounds on the size of the matroid, which may be of independent interest.