Linking size-based and trophic analyses of benthic community structure

Abstract

Models of biomass size spectra assume that organisms with higher body mass feed at higher trophic levels, but explicit empirical tests of this pattern are rare. We used nitrogen stable isotopes (δ 15 N) as an index of the trophic level in a benthic fish and invertebrate size-spectrum, and demonstrated that body mass was positively and significantly related to trophic level. This pattern was consistent with the expectation that predator-prey relationships led to powerful size-based trophic structuring in marine communities and ecosystems. Further analysis of intra-and interspecific relationships between body mass and trophic level in the community showed that increases in trophic level across the size spectrum were predominantly a consequence of intra-specific increases in trophic level with body mass and not a consequence of larger species (species with greater maximum body mass) feeding at higher trophic levels. We confirmed the absence of strong inter-specific relationships between maximum body mass and trophic level with cross-species and phylogenetic comparative approaches. Size-based models are easier and cheaper to parameterise than most food-web models. Subject to the persistence of relationships between body mass and trophic level in space and time, our results suggest that size spectra could be parameterised with body mass-trophic level relationships and used to describe the trophic structure of some marine communities and ecosystems.KEY WORDS: Size-spectra · Trophic level · Food web · Community structure · Stable isotopes · PhylogenyResale or republication not permitted without written consent of the publisher

Degree of intervality of food webs: From body-size data to models

“…The analysis of compartments in empirical ecological networks is best described using body size as a proxy for niche value. In accordance with previous related work, trophic level appears to be a poor proxy for niche value (Jennings et al, 2002;Woodward et al, 2005).…”

Size-selective fishing drives species composition in the Celtic Sea

“…In addition, the parameter representing the maximum gross primary production of a single producer species was derived from data for Northeast Atlantic systems from the Sea Around Us Project (2010). The preferred predator-prey bodymass ratio (which implies a preferred M mat ratio at the population level) was chosen based on data from the North Sea (Jennings et al, 2002). The model also has a parameter determining the volumes of trait spaces available to model species.…”

Mercury bioaccumulation and isotopic relation between Trichiurus lepturus (Teleostei) and its preferred prey in coastal waters of southeastern Brazil

“…However, the prey species of T. lepturus varied in length and weight (and probably age) (Table I). Parameters as consumer class, size, and age may infl uence the isotopic ratios of a given specimen, either alone as combined (Jennings et al 2002, Caut et al 2009). For the shrimp X. kroyeri the feeding habit may explain the lower δ 15 N values, once this species is a benthic feeder whose main feeding resources are small invertebrates and sediment (Branco and Moritz-Júnior 2001).…”