The aim of our paper was to describe what we believe was a case of xanthogranulomatous inflammation in the small bowel of a dog. Xanthogranulomatous inflammation is a well-documented, specific histopathological entity that has been described in detail in human literature [1][2][3][5][6][7] but not in veterinary literature. On the other hand, lipogranulomatous lymphangitis has been described in veterinary medicine as we made perfectly clear in our report, citing amongst others Dr. Van Kruiningen himself. The presence of aggregates of foamy cells intermingled with acute and chronic inflammatory cells, suppurative foci, necrosis, haemorrhages and neovascularization 1-3,5-7 distinguishes xanthogranulomatous inflammation from lipogranulomatous lesions, since lipogranuloma has been described to be devoid of a suppurative component 1,4 .At no point did we ''pretend'' to have discovered a new disease and neither did we propose to rename a previously described disorder. A careful perusal of our report shows that Dr. Van Kruiningen's accusations are groundless and under the circumstances we see no reason to issue a retraction. .