Listening Past the Lies that Make Us Sick: A Voice-Centered Analysis of Strength and Depression among Black Women

Abstract

An emerging feminist paradigm likens depression to silencing, as women disconnect from important aspects of their realities in an attempt to meet cultural standards of feminine goodness. While offering a provocative re-evaluation of hegemonic feminine norms and depressive episodes, little in this literature explores connections between silencing and depression within other, non-white constructions of feminine goodness. Employing a voice-centered method that illuminates areas of conflict between cultural scripts and individual meaning making, I forward that being strong is both the depiction of Black feminine goodness and an important contributor to depressive episodes. Drawing on interview data from a nonclinical sample of 58 Black women, I illustrate three depressionrelevant aspects of Black women's gendered experiences: the promotion of their stoicism, silence, and selflessness through the prevailing discourse of the "strong Black woman"; the active suppression of discourse-discrepant realities which the women associate with depressive experiences; and the psychological healing attendant on supplanting this discourse with experience-based knowledge of their social realities. Voice-centeredness, I conclude, brings a needed sensitivity to depression as a racialized and gendered experience of distress tied to the normative conditions of Black women's lives.Keywords Depression . Silencing . Voice . Strength . Black women The silencing paradigm: A feminist understanding of depression Many women in our society live in an untenable position, wedged between sociocultural expectations and their own human growth potential.... Yet women thirst to be more than the roles and behaviors that are ascribed to them, and therein lies the trap of depression. (Schreiber 1996, p. 490) To explain the fact that women are overwhelmingly the victims of depression, some feminist theorists and researchers have argued that its incidence is tied to normative

Depression and Victimization in a Community Sample of Bisexual and Lesbian Women: An Intersectional Approach

“…One explanation for this pattern of findings may be rooted in what some have termed the “strong Black woman” phenomenon (Beauboeuf-Lafontant, 2008; Nelson, Cardemil, & Adeoye, 2016). This concept suggests that strength “is not an objective description of Black women, but a prescriptive discourse embedded in both racist and sexist characterizations of Black women as laborers for others” (Beauboeuf-Lafontant, 2008, p. 395).…”

Widening the gap: Support gaps in same race versus different race female friendship dyads

“…Women are often asked to attend to the needs of others before themselves (Thoits, 2013). Their caregiving responsibilities are burdensome and often come at the expense of their own mental health and self-care (e.g., Beauboeuf-Lafontant, 2008). Future research can compare women's needs and desires for support and determine whether they set low standards for support that friends from any racial group can surpass.…”

Applying the Stress and ‘Strength’ Hypothesis to Black Women's Breast Cancer Screening Delays

“…Building upon sociological examinations of strength, investigations of the critical role of strength in Black women’s health and wellness are increasing, revealing associations with increased binge eating, anxious and depressive experiences, and obesity, among others (Amankwaa, 2003; Beauboeuf-Lafontant, 2003, 2005, 2008; Black & Peacock, 2011; Edge & Rogers, 2005; Harrington, Crowther, & Shipherd, 2010; Harris-Lacewell, 2001; Woods-Giscombé, 2010; Woods-Giscombé & Black, 2010). Links between strength beliefs and behaviours and delays in Black women’s breast cancer screenings have yet to be made.…”